The price of school safety

It's about $5 million for starters.

That's according to Dr. Del Phillips who is asking for a one-time allocation of $5 million to improve school security in the wake of the school shooting in Sandy Hook, CT. 

Of course, supporting School Resource Officers would become a recurring budget expense.  County Executive Anthony Holt has pledged his full support for the program.

Next, will County Commissioners put up the funds to cover this cost?  And, will they later use this as an excuse for why no additional money is available to properly fund schools?

Tune in to January's County Commission and School Board meetings for more details.

PayDay Loan Company Comes to Hendersonville

Advance Financial, a payday lender, has opened a new store in Hendersonville.  According to their own press release, the company is a comprehensive financial center.

No mention of the predatory lending rates that tend to trap the most vulnerable citizens in a cycle of payday loans -- getting one to pay off the other. 

At one time, many states had laws against usury.  Now, companies like Advance Financial operate with impunity. 

Nevertheless, if you should need a last-minute loan for the Holidays, Advance opened just in time -- and right next to Starbucks.  So, take some of that high interest cash and buy a latte.

But Where Will They Go to School?

Planning Commission gives tentative green light to a 600 home development -- with kids from those houses zoned for Station Camp schools, it seems.  Schools that are already at or over capacity. 

No word yet on plans to either 1) expand Station Camp facilities (on hold because of budget issues) or 2) build new schools in or near the area to accomodate future growth or 3) rezone schools so that over-crowding is less of a challenge.

With this development and the nearly completed apartment complex behind Indian Lake Cinemas, it seems the area is poised for significant growth and in just the areas where schools are already maxed out in terms of space. 

Will these developments lead to a corresponding request by the schools for more capital funds to upgrade existing facilities or build new ones?  Will the School Board start asking cities to slow growth while the schools catch up?

Magnet School Lives up to Name

Merrol Hyde Magnet School is just that.  A magnet.  Lots of demand, a few slots.  At least that's the conclusion one draws from reading this story.

Lots and lots of people want their kids to go there.

And, there's no more room.

And with the current situation in Sumner Schools, it seems unlikely there will be a new magnet program anytime soon.

In fact, the Focus Academy proposal (essentially creating Magnet academies within existing schools) has been scaled back due to funding concerns. 

Sumner citizens clearly want the magnet school concept.  And there is interest in the program.  So far, though, there hasn't been interest in adequately funding the schools. 

Two options exist going forward.  Expand Merrol Hyde Magnet so it can accomodate more students.  Or, build another Magnet school in Gallatin to draw from that geographic area. 

The expansion of MHMS would likely be the least expensive.  But either option is costly in terms of added faculty, facilities, and supplies.  And right now, kids don't all have access to textbooks and the system lacks adequate technology to meet upcoming demands.

In fact, it is projected that the schools will need at least $7 million in technology investment next year to meet Common Core testing requirements.  That's on top of any funds to meet growth needs.  And it is worth noting that 28 teaching positions weren't filled this year as a budget-saving measure -- filling those would cost roughly $1.4 million. 

So, there's a strong, desirable Magnet school.  One.  And for now, (and for years to come, it seems) that's all Sumner will have.

Hendersonville Holiday Recipes

It is the Holiday season and time to cook and bake. 

Last week, we wrote up two great recipes (pumpkin cake and derby pie) and we're looking for more.

If you have a GREAT Holiday recipe you want to share with your Hendersonville friends, email us:  newshendersonville@gmail.com

We'll publish the great-sounding (and tasting) ones for all of Hendersonville to see and share.

County Commission Shopping Spree

Mike Towle takes the County Commission to task for their big spending ways just months after they refused to open the pocketbook for schools. 

Holiday Recipes

Here are two reader submitted Holiday dessert recipes...both sound delicious:

Derby Pie

No, it is NOT Derby season.  But yes, this pie will fit right in to your Thanksgiving table:

Ingredients:

3 eggs
1/2 cup heavy cream
1/2 cup dark corn syrup
2 tsp Vanilla
3 TBSP Bourbon
1/2 cup sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar
1/8 tsp salt
2 TBSP melted butter
1 1/2 cups pecan halves
3/4 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips
9 or 10 inch pie shell

Beat eggs well.  Stir in remaining ingredients.  Add pecans and chocolate chips last.  Bake in a pre-heated 400 degree oven for 35 min.  Cover crust with foil to prevent over-cooking in last 15 mins.  Top with whipped cream and serve


Gooey Pumpkin Cake

1 butter recipe yellow cake mix (Duncan Hines is preferred)
1 egg
1 stick of butter (melted)
Mix above and press down into a 13x9 baking dish

8 oz cream cheese
3 eggs
2 tsp vanilla
1 stick of butter, softened
16 oz box powdered sugar
15 oz can of pumpkin
1 tsp cinnamon
1 tsp nutmeg

mix above with mixer and pour on top of cake mix
Bake at 350 45 minutes or until done in the middle

School Board Meets Tonight

With a rather thorough agenda, including how to handle potential teacher layoffs should they be required next year (hint: absent new county funding, teacher layoffs seem very likely next school year). 

They'll also be discussing the retirement package they plan to offer employees who retire by June 30, 2013. 

County Commission Passes Bailout Bill

Last night, the Sumner County Commission passed a spending package that included a $3 million bailout of the County Insurance Trust. 

Why the bailout?  Because the Trust is $6 million in the red.  That's right, if the Trust were to payout all outstanding claims right now, it'd be at a negative balance of $6 million.  So, adding $3 million and adopting some cost-saving measures will allow the Trust to continue. 

How did it get this way? YEARS of mismanagement by the County Commission.  They consistently under-funded the Trust and now, the chickens are coming home to roost. 

Where's the money coming from?  The Hospital Reserve Fund.  The County has a grand total of nearly $30 million in reserves.  However, during the recent budget battle over schools, Hospital fund money was not allowed to be spent on school funding, even for school capital projects. 

The Commission also approved funding for 3 libraries and an emergency response center. 

It was pointed out that the County can barely operate the libraries it has now.  Comm. Chris Hughes asked how the Millersville Library's long-term operating costs would be covered -- no one could answer this question.  Comm. Goode asked about where the funds would come from to support over $7 million in technology upgrades needed for schools because of federal testing mandates.  No one could answer this.  Comm. Hughes (rumored to be considering a 2014 run for County Executive) asked about the $26 million in outstanding school capital projects that have yet to be funded.  No one had an answer.  Comm. Goode asked about the scrutiny and due diligence paid to these library projects.  Again, no solid answers were given. 

Lots of questions, no answers.  A badly mismanaged insurance trust and a $3 million bailout funded at the expense of other worthy needs.  At the end of the night, the project list passed with a 17-6 vote.  No word on when the community can expect to hear more answers to these critical questions.

Losing Focus?

So, the Focus Academies are going to be more focused on STEM ... and not so much on other things (like health occupations, performing arts, AP, or IB)

Here are some survey results and a presentation that explains what's happening next.

Several reasons.  1) The community at large is most interested in STEM - so, it seems that whatever school got the STEM Academy would be in highest demand -- that was originally Gallatin).  2) Budget issues.  It's not clear at all that the County Commission would support a fully-functional focus academy system  3) Some change is needed to move the district forward -- math continues to be a weakness and there is demand for STEM skills. 

This option is offered as a means of moving toward Focus Academies at a reduced cost.  Of course, the district did not hire 28 needed teachers this year and struggled to start school because of lack of proper funding. 

Capital project money was moved to the General Purpose Fund meaning needed physical improvements have been further delayed. 

There is (was) significant risk that if the District moved ahead with a Focus Academy plan, it would not be funded at the Commission level and therefore would create all kinds of disturbances for students in terms of plans and programs.  Not to mention faculty who may have been hired and then would have to be let go.

So, aside from STEMing the tide of inadequate funding, the focus is on survival. 

$7 million in new spending

So, the County Commission's Budget Committee meets Tuesday at 6 PM to discuss, among other items, spending $7.25 million from the Hospital Reserve Fund.

The Commission is proposing to use these dollars to 1) make up for the giant hole in the insurance trust left by their own mismanagement of the program 2) Fund several possibly worthy public projects.

It is interesting to note that the dollar amount matches almost exactly the dollar amount requested by the School System this year during the budget battle.

It's also interesting that while the County Commission refused to spend the money on schools because the money had to be spent on an "economic development purpose" they are now proposing to use $3 million to balance the insurance trust - which hardly seems an "economic development purpose" and is rather a "crisis avoidance purpose."  The other projects may or may not merit expenditures from the County -- but remember, we didn't seem to have ANY money available for schools back in August.  Now, it's fine to spend over $7 million on a BIG mistake and on special projects.

Again, that meeting is at 6 PM on Tuesday.  Will the Budget Committee authorize these expenditures? Will doing so pass legal muster? Stay tuned ...

Dogs and the Arts

Steve Brown is counting on lovers of the performing arts ... and of dogs to support his campaign:

Steve Brown for Mayor

the positive TV spot:

Tommy Elsten Campaign Commercial

Here it is:  Tommy Elsten's positive spot about why he should be Mayor:

SURGing into an impact

Or so they claim... will SURG sway city voters? And if so, what will a SURG-run Hendersonville look like?

But what if the schools were fully-funded?

Dr. Phillips sent out this email announcing Sumner County's success on the State Report Card.  There's lots of improvement to be noted.  Which means our teachers and staff are doing an amazing job in spite of inadequate funding. 

Here's the message: 

Hello All,


The Tennessee Department of Education released studentperformance data this morning in the 2012 Report Card. As your Director of Schools, I want you all to know how proud I am of each and every one of you. Sumner County made great gains this year, and we need to celebrate those gains. We are all part of the same team – our custodians, bus drivers, cafeteria workers, teachers, teacher assistants, principals, parents, and students; and we each play a pivotal role in our system’s success. The dedication and hard work of each and every one of you contributed to the success of each student, each classroom, each school, and our district. Day-in and day-out, you are on the front lines preparing students for success and expanding their opportunities. For that, I say, “Thank you and congratulations!”


There are too many success areas to mention in this letter, but I do want to give attention to a few. As far as academic achievement, our system improved by one letter grade in two of the four content areas. That’s wonderful! We failed to make an “A” in math by only one point. Had we achieved a 55 in math, our district would have had straight As in achievement.

Math

2011 B

2012 B



Rdg/LA

2011 B

2012 A



SS

2011 A

2012 A



Science

2011 B

2012 A



In grades three through five, we saw the percentage ofstudents performing at proficient and advanced levels increase in all four subject areas, with the most improvement in math. When comparing data from 2010 to 2012, 15.6% more students performed at proficient and advanced levels in math.



The story is the same for grades six through eight. More students performed at the proficient and advanced levels than the past year(s). Again, the percentage of students performing at these levels grew from 28.2% in 2010 to 47.1%, with science seeing an increase from 59.3% to 74.1%.



Our algebra I students were also top-notch performers. Twelve percent more students scored proficient and advanced compared to last school year, and our ACT composite score increased from 20.1 to 20.5.



As far as value added is concerned, Sumner County improved three letter grades, missing a “C” in reading/language arts by one tenth of a point. Math improved by two letter grades!



Math

2011 D

2012 B



Rdg/LA

2011 D

2012 D



SS

2011 C

2012 B



Science

2011 F

2012 D


Our attendance rate is holding steady at 95.9 for K-8 and 94.5 for grades 9-12. This tells me that you make our schools safe, fun, and welcoming environments where students want to be.


Finally, our graduation rate (which is our main purpose) improved from 89.6% in 2011 to 91.2% in 2012.


The true mark of a great school system is its people. I am continually amazed by the willingness of our employees to go the extra mile to do what is needed for our students to realize their greatest potential. I can’t say enough about how proud I am of the hard work and dedication it took from each and every one of you to achieve such impressive results. These resultsshow that we truly are Sumner Strong!


Again, I say, “Thank you!” YOU make THE difference everyday!


Your Director of Schools,


Del R. Phillips III, Ph.D.

An apple for teachers?

House candidate Jeanette Jackson has another press release -- she's standing with teachers.

Full text below:

45th District State House candidate Jeanette Jackson today stated she stands with Sumner County teachers and will fight for them if elected to the General Assembly.



“Our teachers have been under attack,” Jackson said. “The outgoing representative was relentless in her attacks on teachers – from diminishing the role of their professional association to pushing down a clumsy, ineffective evaluation system. Our teachers and schools deserve better.


Jackson noted that her opponent, Courtney Rogers, also supports Maggart’s positions on teachers.


“Courtney Rogers said during the primary that she agreed with Maggart on just about every education issue,” Jackson said. “In fact, Rogers’ describes her own education views as to the right of Maggart. That’s extreme and not right for Sumner County.

Jackson said that as the next state representative for the 45th District, she’ll fight for teachers every single day.


“I’ve worked in a public school for 30 years,” Jackson said. “I work with teachers every day. Our schools only succeed when we support our teachers. It’s time for a representative who will fight to repeal this silly, time-consuming evaluation system that takes time away from meaningful instruction. We need a plan developed by teachers who are in classrooms every day – not designed by bureaucrats in Nashville.


“I’m proud of the work our teachers and school employees do every day and I’ll fight for them every single day when I’m your state representative.”

Hyde, Holt back Rogers

According to her financial disclosure, Courtney Rogers has received donations from Merrol Hyde and Anthony Holt, two of the County leaders who repeatedly stand in the way of increased funding for our schools.  Joining these two, Bob Pospisil, another school funding opponent, also has donated to Rogers.

She earlier received a $400 contribution from Jerry Stone, another frequent critic of school funding.

This fact might be of interest to voters making a decision before Election Day -- Rogers has a base of support that includes the NRA in Washington, DC and the most ardent local opponents of a fully-funded school budget. 

Maggart Takes on Memphis

She's not happy that they can use photo library cards to vote.  TN Report has her story.

Brewer Takes to the Air

State Senate candidate Maria Brewer is out with a new campaign ad:

Aldermanic Money Chase

Or, the story about how County Commissioners Freels, Stone, Pospisil, and Hyde are trying to beat Paul Goode in his race for Alderman...

Looks like Monte Green benefits from animosity among certain County Commissioners and Comm. Paul Goode, also a Hendersonville Alderman.

In other races, Scott Sprouse appears a safe bet for re-election and has been a solid alderman through two terms. 

Kee Bryan-McCormick is running strong, but then so is her opponent, Darrel Woodcock -- Woodcock's support comes from the tea party crowd and an early fundraiser included mayoral candidate Tommy Elsten, tea party State Rep. candidate Courtney Rogers, and tea party School Board member Vanessa Silkwood. 

Look for new faces to greet the next Mayor -- likely Foster or Elsten, but possibly Steve Brown.  Certainly, it won't be Garry Forsythe, rumored to be in consideration for a top post in the "new" Foster administration.

Foster Takes Money Lead into Home Stretch

It seems Scott Foster has the most money remaining in the final days of the Mayor's race.

Steve Brown is next, followed by Tommy Elsten -- who has clearly spent heavily on yard signs and bumper stickers.

Faux candidate Garry Forsythe is far behind, with numbers indicating he is less than serious, despite being a really, really nice guy.

Textbooks vs. Teachers?

According to County Commissioner Jerry Stone, Sumner County can afford EITHER textbooks or teachers, but NOT both.

That's the essence of his comments after a recent County Commission workshop on school funding.

The County Commission is to be commended for finally digging in to the details of how school budgets work.  The workshop, instigated by Commission Chair Merrol Hydge and presented by the County Technical Assistance Service from UT, gave Commissioners information on the BEP (the state's school funding formula) and local allocations. 

At meeting's end, however, Stone (the vice-chair of the budget committee) found fault with the School Board for allocating some BEP funds for teachers and then asking the Commission to fund textbooks. 

He then pointed out that the Commission gave the schools extra money for books.  The reality is that the Commission used accounting gimmicks to move some money from capital funds (thus preventing needed improvements at schools like Gallatin High School and Hendersonville High School) to allow them to be used for books.  Thus, no new money was "given" to schools as Stone suggested.

He further failed to explain the utility of textbooks provided to students without teachers to offer instruction.  Or, perhaps he wants the Board of Education to continue providing teachers but not giving those teachers the resources they need to best educate students? 

Jackson Says Opponent "Bought and Paid For"

The 45th District State House race has been relatively quiet.  Courtney Rogers won an upset victory in the primary over incumbent Debra Maggart.  Jeanette Jackson is the Democratic nominee.  The two have not made much noise and only put out a smattering of signs.

But, Jackson recently sent out a press release attacking Rogers for a campaign funded by DC-based special interest groups.

Here's the text:

45th District State House candidate Jeanette Jackson today touted her independence from special interests as voters began heading to the polls in early voting.

“I’m not owned or paid for by any interest group,” Jackson said. “Voters should know that I’m independent and will go to Nashville to fight for them. On the other hand, my opponent won her primary because of Washington-based special interest money. My campaign’s not about money, it’s about putting people first.


Jackson noted that a Washington-based special interest group spent heavily over the summer to support Courtney Rogers’ successful primary campaign. She said that means Rogers will owe them should she win the General Election.


“She’s bought and paid for, plain and simple,” Jackson said. “You’ve got someone vying to represent us who is a single-issue, special interest candidate. We deserve better. I haven’t taken PAC or special interest money. I won’t anyone any favors after the election. My only focus will be on serving the voters of the 45th District.


Jackson said that as the next state representative for the 45th District, she’ll focus on two important issues: Schools and jobs.

“We deserve excellent schools and investments in education,” Jackson said. “We also need someone who is committed to fighting to bring jobs to Tennessee and Sumner County. I’ve worked 30 years in our schools and I will fight every day for new jobs and opportunity in Sumner County.”

Dog Lovers for Steve Brown

Well, they should be.  In his latest direct mail piece, Mayoral candidate Brown tells voters:

I feel we need to establish some more recreational and passive areas in our park system along with a dog park for our pet lovers.

No word yet on whether or not he'll be proposing a cat tunnel for the city's feline loving families.

County Insurance Trust Faces HUGE Deficit

Years of rising premiums -- and underfunding by the County Commission -- have led to a $6 million deficit in the County Insurance Trust.  The situation could impact more than 1600 County employees insured by the Trust.

County Executive Anthony Holt notes that a $4 million cash infusion would help solidify the trust for now.  Where would those funds come from? The "Hospital" Fund -- that big pot of over $18 million the County is sitting on.  This is in addition to the County's "reserve" fund, which has a balance of $11 million.

Readers might recall that these funds were not "allowed" to be used to help in this year's school budget crisis because they can only be used for "economic development" purposes. 

However, it is hard to see how a one-time expense of $4 million to make up for an under-funded insurance plan furthers economic development.  All it does is prevent a crisis County Commissioners have known about and chosen to ignore. 

And, how is this MORE economic development than say, improving schools? 

The Wellness Initiative seems a reasonable proposal and should likely be undertaken no matter what. 

But for County Commission leaders to call the School Board fiscally irresponsible is simply laughable in light of this revelation. 

Lamberth Maintains Big Money Lead

Backed by a host of big money, Nashville special interests, Republican William Lamberth has maintained a big financial lead over his opponent, Steve Glaser, in the race for the open 44th District House seat -- held by Portland's Mike McDonald for the past 18 years.

Lamberth currently has more than $60,000 in cash on hand with donations from a laundry list of PACs and interest groups.

Glaser has been endorsed by the teachers' association and at least one labor group -- and has received contributions from them.  But, his more modest haul reflects donations mainly from individuals.  His cash on hand reported was $14,000.

The final weeks of the campaign have seen the race heat up.  Lamberth's money lead could be the deciding factor.

Mayoral Candidate Forum

The four men running to be Mayor of Hendersonville participated in a forum this week where they discussed their plans for the City.

Incumbent Mayor Scott Foster expressed his belief that things are going well and we should continue following his proposed path.

The other four, to some degree, differed with Foster.  Alderman Tommy Elsten and Alderman Steve Brown offered the most pointed criticism, with Brown noting "blight" in the city that has gone unaddressed.  Elsten focused his attacks on drainage issues that continue to plague residents.

Forsythe agreed he voted with Foster most of the time.  But, he said, he offers years of experience in finance that could help keep the city on-track.

Turn ON the Lights

At least in a couple subdivisions, anyway.  The lights are coming to brighten dark streets. 

Greene Backs Jackson

In the race for 45th District State Representative, Tara Greene is backing Jeanette Jackson.  She says so in this letter:

Dear Editor,



For the first time a new name for Representative of the 45th District will be on the general election ballot on November 6. Jeanette Jackson was chosen by the people of Sumner County, in the August Primary, to represent them as a candidate to oppose Courtney Rogers.


Jackson, a mother of three, an employee of the Sumner County School System for 28 years and a resident of the 45th District for 34 years, intends full dedication to THE PEOPLE of this district, with no monetary influence from any lobbyists when making legislative decisions, as to what is desired and best for the families she would be so honored to represent.


A vote for Jackson is a vote for a fight for the voice of teachers to be heard once again. It is a vote for the families of Sumner County and all of Tennessee to be served with their well-being first and foremost as a priority and concern. It is a vote for a true representative of the people of the 45thDistrict to go to the Capitol and bring with her, the voices of all in this community and not the sole voices of a few major campaign donors.


Jackson’s opponent, Courtney Rogers, apparently has at least two issues of concern for the families, schools and businesses of the 45th District. “I might have as many as two issues,” Rogers has been quoted as saying. “I might have guns AND ammunition as issues.” This would indeed imply that she is being true to her major funding source.

Jackson has more than two issues of concern for the families of the 45th District. If you have the opportunity to hear Ms. Jackson in a debate with her opponent you will hear these expressions. “My passion is to bring forth the opportunity for 21st Century jobs to Tennesseans, to fight for the Tennessee First Jobs Act, to provide a means to affordable health care to all, to concentrate on fully funded public education, to review and amend sensible tax reform in our state and to fully respect the 2ndamendment of our U.S. Constitution by being a proponent of responsible gun ownership legislation.” This is Jackson’s response when asked what her issues and concerns would be if she were so honored to represent the People of the 45th.

Primary voting is over. The General Election will bring the voters a choice for a new beginning. A well informed electorate is the basis to a strong community. Know your heart. Know the candidate’s intents. Know that Democracy has spoken when you see the two choices for the 45th District. The people have spoken and it is Jackson vs. Rogers in 2012

Tara Greene

Fuzzy Numbers and Lunch with Ted

The County Commission's Education Committee got a dose of explanation for fuzzy numbers from the School Board.  And, Committee members expressed interest in eating lunch with new Board Chair Ted Wise. 

Mr. Hyde noted that he and Benny Bills, who traded places as Director of Schools over a nearly 40-year period ... interrupted only briefly by short-timer Levon Hubbard ... could do math and predict student numbers and reserve balances.

What he didn't say was how the system could go on for so long without adequate technology, no Pre-K program, and PTOs paying for basic school supplies.  Or, how he proposed that the school system compete with higher salaries for teachers offered in nearby districts.  He failed to mention poor planning in terms of facilities and zoning or a lack of interest in accounting for predictable growth in certain zones -- zones which now have overcrowded schools (Madison Creek, Station Camp, and Jack Anderson come to mind). 

So, Merrol can do math.  And Benny could, too.  But did either of them have a vision of excellence for our community's schools?

Republicans want it back

The 44th District House seat in Tennessee, that is.  They had it once before, all the way back in 1972.  But since then, the seat has been held by Democrats, most recently for 18 years by Mike McDonald of Portland.  Now, redistricting gives the Tennessee GOP a good shot at getting the seat back.  The race pits Steve Glaser against William Lamberth. 

For more on both men, go here.

They've got Vision

The four candidates running for Mayor of Hendersonville recently attended a forum and stated their visions for the city.  The candidates -- incumbent Mayor Scott Foster, Vice-Mayor Garry Forsythe, Alderman Steve Brown and Alderman Tommy Elsten -- each offered their thoughts on what could make Hendersonville, TN even better.

While Foster, Brown, and Elsten have raised significant sums and are running serious campaigns, it is difficult to tell why Forsythe is in the race and if he's even really running. 

Nevertheless, there's more about the forum and the answers from the candidates here.

The money is rolling in ...

The tax money, that is.  Well, not exactly rolling in ..but, sales tax collections are up 9% over the same time period last year.  That means more money is going to the school system - a system desperately in need of new investment.

If these numbers hold, it could make it easier for the County Commission to invest additional funds in the school system in the 2013-14 budget year.  With increased sales tax collections, the dollar amount needed for a property tax increase for schools could be kept fairly low -- around $50-$60 a year per family. 

What's your theme?

You can tell the school system what theme you like ... for high school ..via a survey at sumnerschools.org

You can read more about the proposal here.

Lamberth Fires Back

After a barrage of Steve Glaser press releases attacking his ethical integrity, William Lamberth is firing back -- by way of his friends at the TNGOP.  Lamberth is focusing on Glaser's difficulty paying his bills ... even his taxes. 

More here.

Glaser Keeps the Heat on Lamberth

This time, it is all about alleged violations of the Hatch Act.  While this sounds pretty serious, we're betting Lamberth won't bow out of the race OR resign. 

Glaser, Lamberth race heating up

Steve Glaser and William Lamberth, candidates for the 44th District House seat being vacated by Mike McDonald, are heating up the race -- lobbing attacks at each other in an attempt to sway voters.

Glaser accuses Lamberth of the appearance of impropriety for taking campaign cash from family members and attorneys involved in cases before the DA's office (Lamberth is an assistant DA). 

Lamberth continues to harp on bankruptcy in Glaser's past. 

See it all here.

Numbers Game

So, just as school is finally settled in to its routine...students and teachers are back and have been for several weeks now -- the "numbers" are coming out. That is, the student enrollment numbers.  Once projected to be at least 1200 more students than last year, the reality is there are about 300 MORE students than last year.  Now, that's still a steady increase ... but a lot less than was projected right in the middle of a heated budget fight.

The explanation doesn't seem to make much sense, either.  Something about transfers in and out of school and in and out of county.  Now, the transfer numbers this year were actually LOWER than they were last year over the same period.  And the estimate of new students was based on the transfer number.  So, if this year's transfer numbers were lower, it seems this year's growth numbers would also be lower. 

On the other hand, the school system did have a challenge in terms of its data management system. Still, it seems staff either arrived at really inaccurate numbers OR knew the real numbers and inflated them to gain leverage in the budget fight. 

Now, the issue of gaining leverage seems to have a significant risk for the school system. First, it was and is clear that the County Commission simply wasn't going to fully fund the school system's budget this year.  So, artificially inflating numbers in the heat of battle would seem to be of little benefit.  Second, the pesky thing with numbers is they eventually become REAL, not estimates.  So, if they were intentionally inflated, someone had to know the truth would be revealed and look bad.  No Director would knowingly want to be exposed in this way.

The most credible explanation, it seems, is that personnel changes and staff error contributed to an inflated number being presented.  While that may be understandable, it certainly shouldn't be the norm.  More questions should have been asked before those numbers were released to the County Commission and the public. 

The bottom line is that our school system is growing and adding students.  300 more this year than last.  And our schools remain poorly funded relative to peer districts.  Transparency and accuracy will go a long way toward building the public's trust as the community seeks solutions and a way forward. 

Bug Off!

There are bedbugs at Oakmont Elementary. But, the school is NOT infested.

Still, makes for some unpleasant, itchy class sessions...and, the potential that bedbugs may go home with kids.   

Time to Get Some Knowledge

The Sumner County Commission is set to learn all about how school system budgets work -- AFTER the latest round of budget turmoil. 

Perhaps this session will prevent future budget crises. 

Or, help clear up misunderstandings.

One thing that might be nice is if the budget masters teach about calendars.

A Wise Change?

Ted Wise will now Chair the Sumner County School Board.  Beth Cox will be vice-chair.  The two replace Don Long, who declined a nomination for a fourth term and Danny Hale, who is no longer on the Board after not running for re-election this year. 

Wise and Cox both expressed a desire to reach out to the County Commission and build a stronger relationship with that body. 

The Star News has more.

Towle and the Golden Ticket

It runs right through Vol State Community College.  It's about jobs and opportunity.  And, it's on target.

What was never lost can't be found ...

Or, the story of the missing money...that wasn't ever missing.

County Commissioner Jim Vaughn accused the school system of "hiding" money or..."finding" new money after the budget process started.

Director of Schools Del Phillips says, nope.  It didn't happen that way.  The money trail was documented the entire way.

The documents, available at SumnerSchools.org, seem to back Phillips up. 

Tonight, we'll see the County Commission in action -- and we'll surely hear mention of this "hot" issue. 

Will more money turn up?  Will the mystery of the never lost money be solved?  Tune in at 7 PM in Gallatin for the answers.

Losing Focus

Tonight, the County Commission meets. 

Among the items for discussion:  The final school system budget.  This vote will end a months-long battle that included a nearly two-week delay of school.  The budget includes likely layoffs as the gap between what the Board of Education requested and County Commission funded started at over $7 million and ended up at just under $900,000.  This was due in part to accounting gimmicks by the Commission that shifted capital funds for schools into operating funds -- thus, no new money was added, but the funds were "repurposed."

Also on the agenda is a resolution encouraging the Board to eliminate 7 Focus Coordinator positions instead of laying off classroom instructors.  Since no layoffs have yet been made or announced, this vote may be premature.  Of course, the County Commission is certainly within their rights to recommend by resolution, but they can't dictate the school system's budget.

After tonight, when the budget is expected to pass, look for both bodies to continue the discussion about schools and funding. Or, to do more of the same and wait until next budget year for another crisis that could have been avoided.

Del Phillips Writes a Letter to Jim Vaughn

Well, really, it is a letter to the entire community. But it addresses the concerns raised by "one commissioner."  And guess who it is?  Jim Vaughn.

Here's the letter:

Last night the County Budget Committee approved our 2012-13 General Purpose Budget and passed it on to the full County Commission for consideration.
This budget contains $2.5 million in reductions from the needs-based budget initially approved by our School Board on July 17, 2012, including a $935,000 reduction in personnel that the school system will be carrying out over the next few weeks. These cuts are in addition to over $3.3 million that was cut from last year’s budget.
I am disappointed that despite all our efforts to communicate accurate,up-to-date information about our budget and basic accounting processes, the people of Sumner County continue to receive inaccurate information and accusatory comments from our funding source. Many of you may have received such information last night from one County Commissioner.
In order to balance this year’s budget, our School Board allocated $5.3 million from our final reserve fund, the maximum amount that can be used by state law. The available reserve amount that can be used for funding is always an estimate until the year-end financials are closed. We are very fortunate that this year’s final reserve balance was positively impacted by a combination of expense reductions/savings and the final revenue amount.

Please note that we did not receive the final revenue amount from the County until August. Please also note that until the final actualization of last year’s savings were realized and until the County gave us our final revenue, we were unable to determine a final reserve balance. Without this final reserve balance, we did not know what would be available for 2012-2013 spending.


It is also important to point out that just like in years past, the original budget presented had an estimated reserve balance until the books were closed and final numbers realized. This has always been the procedure for the School System and the County General. Nothing changed this year. I am proud to say that our System, operating on last year’s $188,375,680 budget, closed its fiscal books before our County General, operating on a $46,377,920 budget.


Until our County Commission realizes our need for a long-term sustainable solution, the funding will continue to be inadequate. Layoffs will continue to be inevitable, and the need for transparency will grow.
I have said all along, that conversation is good. This year’s budget process has started a conversation that will be continued until a long-term, sustainable solution is reached.

However, it saddens me that when we should be having a conversation about our district’s future, we are instead forced to discuss what student services to cut.

It is easy to get caught up in the political rhetoric. This blame game takes the focus off of the issue at hand – which is fighting for our students to have the best education possible and fighting for our teachers to have the resources to provide that education.


We began in August of 2011 communicating the needs of this system. I feel we have done so in a professional and thorough way. Our County Commission had every opportunity to fully fund our budget. They did not. Let me encourage you to not let this take the focus off of what is important, our students.

Our students deserve the adults and leadership of Sumner County to be professional, proactive, and responsible. Our ultimate goal is to provide the best education possible for every child in Sumner County.

Your Director of Schools,

Del R. Phillips III, Ph.D

Jim Vaughn vs. the Budget

So, the underfunded school system budget passed last night at the Budget Committee.  It will be voted on by the full Commission on Monday, September 17th.

One Commissioner, Jim Vaughn, sent out a facebook post and contact NewsChannel5 about what he called the "truth" about the budget.

He claims the Board "found" money after schools were closed on August 2nd.  Then says this "finding" was hidden from the public.  He asserts that this is but one example of the Board's lack of transparency. 

There's only one problem.  The Board DID disclose the money.  At the initial budget presentation, the Board offered an estimate.  By the August 21st Board meeting (school was already BACK in session by then), the Board was including the very likely to occur revenue in its budget projections as a means of bridging the gap between the Board proposal and the County Commission's funding offer.  So, these dollars were known about and publicly available on August 21st.  Jim Vaughn said nothing then.  Not until last night did he complain about this.  And his complaint further suggests that these funds represent "new" money, when he knows (or should know) this is not true. 

It's worth noting that this is the same Jim Vaughn who argues that shifting money from one pot to another is the same as a budget increase -- yes, he was behind the accounting gimmick that "gave" the School Board money that was already earmarked for School Board projects -- thus, defunding those projects -- and then turned around and called that a funding increase. 

Jim Vaughn is taking on the facts of the budget.  But, the budget is winning.

County Budget Committee Meets

They will discuss the recently approved school system budget.

This is a budget that could result in the layoffs of up to 17 teachers by the end of this month.  It could also result in significant cuts to Adult Education, eliminating $400,000 from a budget just under $750,000.  That would mean additional layoffs to current employees of the Adult Ed. program. 

This is the final committee step before the full County Commission takes its probably last action on the school system's budget for this year.  That will come next week (Sept. 17th) when the Commission meets to approve or reject the Budget Committee's recommendation. 

It is possible that someone who voted against one of several earlier proposals to fund schools (a small tax increase, using reserves) could initiate discussion on the issue again by way of offering to change their vote.  That would re-open the issue for debate and a possible vote.  Failing that action, the Commission will likely pass the budget and the Board will proceed with programmatic and staff cuts. 

Of course, September 17th is well past the July 1st beginning of the fiscal year for the schools and county.  They've been operating on a continuation budget since then because they couldn't do their business in a more timely fashion. 

And, barring new revenue or more responsible action on the part of the County Commission, there will be further cuts next year as the school system keeps on growing and will most certainly require additional monies to operate. 

And We Have a Budget (for Schools)

The School Board this week officially approved its budget -- underfunded by some $7 million because of a lack of adequate funds from the County Commission.  The new budget means cuts to personnel across the district, a mix of certified and classified staff.  As many as 17 teachers could be laid off depending on numbers after new applications for early retirement are processed and posistions shifted.

The budget passed 10-1, the lone dissenter being District 1's Vanessa Silkwood. Silkwood continues to push for an unproven outsourcing model that has been rejected 4 times now by her Board colleagues.  Silkwood claims savings that could not be realized this year because of bidding rules.  And research by other Board members indicates outsourcing costs more money in the long-term and decreases the security in schools. 

While the Board has seen an unprecedented level of cooperation recently, Silkwood remains an angry, lonely, dissenting voice -- pushing for options that are unproven -- or, in some cases, proven not to work. 

The passage of this year's budget sets up a 2013-14 budget scenario that could see further cuts to teachers in spite of unprecedented student growth this year.  The only remaining source of revenue is a school fund referendum on the November ballot.  If passed, it could generate $3 million in steady, reliable income dedicated specifically for schools. 

Schools Growing at Rapid Pace

Despite another year with funding challenges caused by a budget battle between the School Board and County Commission, the Sumner County Schools are seeing enormous growth in student population with an increase of more than 1200 students over the same time period last year.

The growth is putting an added strain on a district that will soon be forced to layoff a number of teachers because the County Commission rejected its budget request. 

Local investment in Sumner Schools has dropped in recent years and now represents only 32% of total revenue spent on schools.  Statewide, the average is 39% local funding. 

Sumner is one of the top 5 wealthiest counties in the state and has the lowest property tax rate of any county touching Davidson in middle Tennessee.  The last property tax increase was 9 years ago. 

Despite incredible growth in student population and a clear increase in costs over the past 9 years, the County Commission has steadfastly refused to consider new measures for generating revenue and dedicating it to the school system. 

The only possibility for new funds for schools in the near future is a referendum that would increase the wheel tax -- effectively costing the average family less than a dollar a week -- and generate some $3 million annually that is dedicated exclusively for schools. 

The referendum specifically spells out that all monies generated from the school fund referendum will go to the general purpose fund of the schools.  Voters would have to approve any change in that designation by way of a referendum -- the County Commission has no power to take those funds away from schools. 

Mike Towle Hearts Debra Maggart

He says so right here!  He even mentions that he's pining for her return...

They Meet Tonight

Both the Sumner County School Board and the County Commission's Education Committee meet tonight.

What's on their mind?

For the School Board, it's money!

And for the County Commission, also money!

Dr. Phillips will be busy driving as both meetings start at 6 PM...

Spending on Dogs = Growth

Or, something like that.  Mayoral candidate Tommy Elsten is worried about too much out of control city spending.  Mayor Foster, running for a third term, is focused on promoting the city's growth.  And Steve Brown says all these new people brought their dogs, so now we need a dog park. 

Also, Garry Forsythe still claims he's a viable candidate. 

It's all right here.

Sticking Around

Mike Towle tells us the Rep. Debra Maggart is sticking around. 

But how would he have paid for it?

Sure, Danny Hale tabled an ill-conceived policy about renaming schools.  And yes, he's no longer on the Board.  But after he helped spearhead the effort to rename Knox Doss Middle School to Station Camp - at a cost approaching $100,000, he proposed a policy that would almost surely have meant renaming another county school, at a cost estimated at $500,000.  This despite his recurring plea that the Board should only act in the best interests of the students. 

Nevermind that he supported a budget nearly $8 million out of balance -- he thinks the Board should spend tax dollars renaming schools for political reasons. 

The proposal, now tabled, may simply languish and be forgotten.  As for Hale, it's not clear what's next on his agenda. 

Don't Call it a Comeback ...

... Will Mike McDonald run again soon?  It sure sounds like it is possible.  Governor 2014?  A state Senate seat in four years?  He's making a case that he's sticking around...

Mississippi Yearning?

Del Phillips clearly, emphatically says NO!  Plus, they haven't even started a search process yet, so it's not likely he's applied for a job that is not officially open ...

Not a Good Start

Well, this is probably not how Pamela Tidwell wanted to start her campaign...

A Kindergarten View

Brenda Payne of the Hendersonville Chamber suggests our School Board and County Commission may needt to go back to Kindergarten and learn the rules.  Some of them just need to spend some time in our schools ...

Del's Coming to Campus

And he's got a warning, too:  This budget problem is NOT going away.  If you think 2012 is bad, wait until 2013.  Which sounds a lot like the message he gave in 2011...

Anyway, here goes:

Hello All,
Last night our Board took action to address the budget shortfall for this school year. I understand how difficult this process has been for our employees, parents, and students, but I also want you to know that we did all we could to proactively address our funding issue. Last night’s Board actions are summarized below:


•The proposed distance learning program has been eliminated.

•The Global Positioning System (GPS) for buses has been eliminated.

•Pay raises for certified and classified personnel were reduced from 3% to 2.5%.

•Our Adult Education program remains unbudgeted; however, the Education Committee of the County Commission is taking this program under advisement and will be discussing this program at their next regularly scheduled meeting. This program will remain functioning under normal operations until further notice.

•Despite all of our efforts, personnel reductions are necessary. In an effort to minimize these reductions as much as possible, the Board approved an extension of the 2011-2012 retirement benefits for both certified and classified employees through September 5, 2012. An employee desiring to retire must declare their intent to retire in writing to the Human Resources Department by the close of business on September 5, 2012. Retirement benefit levels are posted on our website and are also attached to this memo. Any vacancy created by an employee electing to retire now could create opportunities for internal transfers and lessen the number of potential reductions.

We will now begin the process of meeting with principals to identify areas in which we can reduce personnel with a minimal amount of impact to our students. We want to make decisions that are thoughtful and strategic; therefore, it may take some time to complete the reduction process.

This year’s budget situation has been arduous, and I want to remind everyone that the systemic issues affecting the long-term health of our system have not been resolved. We have done our absolute best to manage cuts that balance this year's budget, but our funding issues will continue to persist without a commitment on the part of our funding body to work with us in finding a path forward.
I want everyone in our school system to know that I am proud to be a part of our Sumner County Schools, and I am honored to work alongside our teachers and support personnel, who have all shown tremendous resolve throughout this process. I will be on every campus in the coming weeks to visit with you and help answer your questions. Once again, thank you for your support and thank you for all that you do each and every day.
Sincerely,



Del R. Phillips III, Ph.D.
Director of Schools

And we have a School Calendar

After a delay of eight days, Sumner County students went back to school on August 16th.  The School Board and County Commission didn't really come to an agreement -- it was more like the Commission said "no" and the Board figured it out.  And by figuring it out, the Board will have to make $935,000 in personnel cuts to balance this year's budget. 

In any case, there is now an official school calendar.  It includes a shortened Fall Break, loss of day off just before Thanksgiving, and a much shorter Holiday break around Christmas.  Also, Spring Break is moved to later in March.

Still, school's out before the end of May.  This should allow for a 2 month summer and minimal disruption at the start of next year.  Minimal, that is, except that we'll be short teachers and growth will require new teachers and it is not clear where funding will come from to hire them.  Program cuts or more layoffs seem possible in 2013-14 unless a more permanent funding solution can be agreed upon.

 

Bet they don't mean Gene Brown ...

...since they're talking about spending $ on renaming schools, it seems this is clearly aimed at Gene Brown, Benny Bills, or Merrol Hyde. Wonder which one?

Groundhog Day

...says Mike Towle in this piece pointing to a clear path forward, if only the School Board and County Commission would get on it.

Wheel Tax Rolls to November Ballot

Last night, the Sumner County Commission courageously passed the buck and placed a Wheel Tax before voters on the November ballot.  The wheel tax increase of $25 per car would be dedicated to schools and could only be redirected if voters approved the redirection in another referendum.  So, if it passes, it will generate a dedicated $2.5 - $3 million each year for local schools. 

However, by failing to address the immediate budget challenge at last night's meeting, the Commission placed the School Board in a quandary heading into tonight's meeting.  With uncertainty about funds, the Board faces potential cuts that could include layoffs.  But, if the Wheel Tax passes and goes into effect in December, the funds would be available to prevent most, if not all, of the layoffs.

Does the Board move ahead with layoffs now...or will it wait until November to decide?

And, what about Adult Education?  The program is no longer in the school system's budget.  What does that mean?  School opened last week.  Presumably, Adult Education is working right now.  But, with no source of funding for the 2012-13 academic year, it is uncertain whether the program will continue operating beyond September, when the County Commission approves the final School Board budget.  Absent a $400,000 allocation from the County, Adult Education and its 9 employees will be gone.  The program serves some 1200 citizens each year. 

Tonight's Board meeting will also address calendar issues created by the delay of the school start date. 

Wheel Tax Coming?

Tonight's County Commission agenda includes discussion and/or action on a $25 increase to the Wheel Tax.  Specifically, the agenda item calls for such a tax to be voted on in a referendum to be held in conjunction with the November 6th General Election.

Some are calling on the Commission to just go ahead and implement the increase now.  After all, if passed in November, the tax wouldn't take effect until December -- so the school system would lose 3 months of revenue.

While it seems clear the Commission is not yet ready to pass a property tax increase to fund schools and other obligations, a Wheel Tax potentially has the votes to pass.  If passed in its proposed form, the tax increase would generate $2.5 million or slightly more each year for schools.  While that's not enough to make up what the School System needs to fully fund its programs, it would generate sufficient funds to avoid layoffs this school year. 

The meeting starts at 7 PM and could have an impact on tomorrow night's Board meeting which will address the school calendar and budget. 

Dear Giant, Please Stay Awake!!

Tena Lee's plea for sustained community engagement.

And They're Off...

... the filing deadline has passed and we now have our candidates for Mayor and Alderman.

Haslam Talks Sumner

And basically, he says the kids need to be in school...

The Best They Could Do?

The Sumner County Commission met in another emergency session last night to discuss funding for a revised School Board budget.

The meeting began with Chairman Merrol Hyde recognizing Comm. Mike Akins.  Akins proposed a "voluntary donation fund" that would be used to benefit the schools. Comm. Jim Vaughn pointed out that the County already has a "voluntary fund" and so does not need another one.  It was agreed that the two funds would be combined and benefit the schools. 

Immediately following the approval of this supposedly serious proposal, there was silence.  Chairman Hyde indicated that if there were no further motions, the Commission would adjourn.  As he raised his gavel to end the meeting, Comm. Paul Decker sought recognition.  Decker proposed a 10 cent property tax increase dedicated to the schools. 

The motion was seconded and debated at length, but ultimately failed -- garnering only 8 votes. 

The meeting then went on well past 10:00.  Various proposals were debated and discussed to give the schools additional funds -- they needed $2.7 million to fully fund a budget they had revised on Thursday. 

Time after time, these proposals were rejected. 

Surprisingly, Comm. Jim Vaughn stated repeatedly that the people have spoken and they don't want more taxes.  This in spite of an overflow crowd of several hundred -- 99% of which indicated support for the schools budget and a tax increase -- for the second consecutive Monday.

Ultimately, the Commission pulled another accounting trick.  Last week, the Commission moved $2.2 million it had planned to spend on school capital projects (buildings and facilities) to school capital outlays (books, computers).  This time, the Commission moved another $800,000 from the capital fund dedicated to schools, this time moving it into the school system's general purpose budget.  Again, while this means some budget items, this time including salaries, can be met with these funds -- it also means that $800,000 in potential capital needs will go unmet. 

A Goode Question

Comm. Paul Goode spent considerable time questioning Finance Director David Lawing regarding the County's available reserves.  After reading off a long list of line items, Lawing reported a total reserve balance of $30 million.  Despite having such a healthy reserve balance, the Commission refused to spend a single dollar of reserves on the schools budget. 

What About Glen Kirby?

Gallatin resident Glen Kirby joined a chorus of current and former adult education students who spoke to the merits of the program. The School Board asked the County Commission to cover the cost of adult education this year, just as they had last year.  Kirby noted that he has two sons, one who graduate from UT and another soon to graduate from MTSU.  Kirby himself never graduated from high school, but through the adult education program, earned a GED and is now a college student.  The adult education program serves more than 1200 students each year.

A Free Ride for Freels?

After the meeting, Comm. Frank Freels hopped into an Emergengy Management vehicle and said he needed a ride.  It is not clear whether taxpayer-funded rides to and from County Commission meetings are the norm. 

What's next?

The School Board will meet and discuss what to do about the shortfall left by the County Commission.  It seems likely that cuts will need to be made, possibly including employees.  And, unless funds are found, the entire adult education staff will be unemployed.  School may start as early as Thursday, but could be delayed until Monday in order to accomodate class reallocations if teachers are laid off. 

County Commission Meets Tonight

And they will discuss the School Board's amended budget -- which requires an additional $2.7 million to be balanced.  That money could come from a reallocation of existing dollars or some shift in the tax allocation to schools or use of reserve funds.  It will NOT involve a tax increase of any kind.

If the budget passes, the School Board will have a meeting Tuesday night and school could return as early as Wednesday, but more likely, Thursday.

If the budget does NOT pass, it is unclear what is next.  The School Board would have to have a longer, more in-depth meeting to consider cuts, it seems. This may further delay the start of school.  And while there are some items that could be cut without cutting jobs, it seems inevitable that if this budget is not passed, jobs -- teaching jobs -- would be lost. 

So, what does the vote look like going into tonight's meeting?

Here's a breakdown based on last Monday's votes and on historic voting records in terms of school budgets:

LIKELY YES

Ben Harris
Baker Ring
Chris Hughes
Shawn Utley
Paul Decker
David Kimbrough
Michael Guthrie
Paul Goode
Trish LeMarbre

POSSIBLE YES

Paige Brown Strong

LIKELY NO

Billy Geminden
Jerry Stone
Kirk Moser
Merrol Hyde
Jim Vaughn
Joe Matthews
Frank Freels
Mike Akins
Moe Taylor
Bob Pospisil

POSSIBLE NO

David Satterfield
Paul Freels
Jo Skidmore
Steve Graves


Going in, it looks like 10 solid "no" votes and 9 solid "yes" votes.  Should Brown-Strong vote YES, it is a 10-10 tie.  It takes 13 votes to pass the budget. 

All listed in the "possible no" category have voted against the most recent school funding proposals and have historically had difficulty supporting schools budgets.  That would make it 14-10.  If the pro-schools side can move 3 of those votes, they would get the budget passed 13-11.

Of course, there could be amendments and additional proposals that come from the floor during debate.  Some modified version of the budget could gain a majority. 

Could be a long, interesting meeting. 

Del Phillips Works the Inbox

In the ongoing campaign for fully funded Sumner County Schools, Director Dr. Del Phillips has been waging an email and video campaign to make the case for schools.

Here's his latest letter:



Hello all,
Last night our School Board voted unanimously to send a compromise budget request back to our County Commission for funding.


This morning, I hand delivered a copy of our revised budget and a letter to County Executive Anthony Holt and County Commission Chairman Merrol Hyde requesting the County Commission schedule a special-called meeting on Monday, August 13, 2012 to consider our request for a funding compromise.

It is the School Board’s and my desire to get our students back in class as soon as possible; therefore, the Board is also prepared tonotice a follow-up Special Called Meeting for early next week to discuss and act upon the measures taken by the County Commission on Monday evening.

We are requesting that our funding body, the County Commission, provide us with an additional $2.765 million in revenue by reallocating unencumbered funds from capital outlay.


The budget adopted by our School Board last night represents our best attempt at trying to work within the limits placed on our system by our funding body without having to reduce teachers.


I want to thank everyone who has called their County Commissioner, Board Member, or attended one of the public meetings to express support for our schools. I have been thrilled with the number of people in our community who have been engaged in this debate, and I am proud to see the overwhelming support for our schools in the community.

It is my hope that commissioners will understand the needs of our school system and vote to fund our compromise budget on Monday night, so that we can get on with the business of opening schools and fulfilling our core mission of educating students.

Your Director of Schools,

Del R. Phillips III, Ph.D.

Will Our Kids Be in School Next Week...

....Or, what does the Board of Education's action tonight mean?

The Board accepted the $2.2 million from the County Commission -- even though this essentially means $2.2 million in capital projects will go unfunded, the Board has accepted the Commission's offer and this reduces the amount the Board needs to have a fully-funded budget.

The Board then also made some changes to budget assumptions.  And, the Board made some cuts -- including the hiring of 8 new guidance counselors, the entire adult education program, and some cuts to Central Office staff.

With those cuts in place, the Board needs $2.7 million from the County Commission -- down from $7.6 million they were asking for on Monday.

This seems to be a long way toward compromise. 

So, can school start next week?

YES!  But, the County Commission would have to call an emergency meeting for Monday night.  If so, the School Board could meet either later Monday or, more realistically, Tuesday.  School could be back by Thursday.  Possibly Wednesday if certain logistics can be worked out.

But, what if the County Commission doesn't call a special meeting for Monday?  Then, we're back at the stalemate.  No budget for schools means schools don't open. 

And, what if the County Commission meets but doesn't fund the budget?

Dr. Phillips passed out a paper with funding cuts that would impact each school.  Essentially, he'd distribute the $2.7 million in cuts to every school in the district, with principals having the final say on what gets cut at their school.  For almost every school, at least one teacher would have to be let go.  In some schools, it could be a teacher and some support staff.  In some, multiple teachers would be laid off.

The County Commission can avoid all of this and our kids could be back in school by Thursday.  But only IF they meet on Monday and pass the Board's budget.

Dr. Phillips Writes Letters, too!

Here's his letter:

Hello all,




I want to thank everyone who contacted their commissioner or attended the Special Called County Commission meetings in support of SumnerCounty Schools.

Although the majority of our funding body did not vote to address a long-term solution to our funding issue, we are grateful to each and every commissioner that voted to approve the purchase of textbooks from capital funds. It has been very encouraging to our School Board and me to see the overwhelming support for our schools. It is exciting to finally be engaged in a long needed in-depth discussion about the needs of our district in an open forum.

While we appreciate the commission’s gesture of appropriating $2.2 million in one-time money to cover some of this year’s capital expenses, unfortunately this action does little to help the long-term health and vision of our school district.

This afternoon our chairman noticed a special called meeting of our School Board for Thursday, August 9 to discuss our options, as we move forward. It is our hope that our Board can reach a compromise with our funding body, a compromise that will support the long-term needs of our school district.

However, at this meeting I cannot recommend to the School Board that we open schools until this budget impasse is resolved.


I want to reassure all our parents and students that the School Board and I desire to provide only the best education - an educationthat puts our students at a competitive advantage over students from other school districts across the state.
Our schools are already reaching maximum capacity, and we will need new teachers for new students as we continue to grow. Instead, we are looking at reducing our number of teachers.

I believe that, without a doubt, we are at a crossroads. Without attention to this urgent issue, we will be forced to cut our number of teachers and eliminate many educationalopportunities for our students.


Is this the message we want to send to prospective citizens thinking about moving to our wonderful county? What about businesses that locate to an area simply because of the school system? And what message does this send to our students about the importance of their education?

Last fall I made the point loud and clear that if our funding body, the Sumner County Commission, could not support our budgetaryneeds and support our growing population, then cuts to the classroom were inevitable. I can only assume that our County Commission did not take this warning seriously.

Our School Board has made every effort to be forthright, and we have acted in good faith to work with our commissioners. We submitted our budget earlier than it has ever been submitted.


We have made numerous presentations in open public sessions, including the Sumner County budget and education committees in both June and July.

My message today is a plea for our county commission to recognize that our population continues to grow, while our school funding from local revenue sources continues to decrease. This path is simply unsustainable.

I cannot in good conscience start school knowing that our students will have to deal with losing their classroom teacher, class schedules being rearranged, and substitute courses implemented in the middle of the school year.


It is not fair to our students, and it puts them at a distinct disadvantage because we jeopardize student performance under thesecircumstances. We place at risk the ability of our students to earn scholarships.

Last year, Sumner County students earned right at $30 M in scholarships. For every parent and tax payer, that is a large return on investment!

I am asking you to please get engaged in this debate. As a parent or student, you know what impact reducing classroom teachers would have on you personally. If the commission refuses to support our school request, we will have no choice but to start the year with fewer teachers at each and every school.


We want to get back to school as soon as possible. Please contact your commissioner and ask them to work with us to keep teachers and staff in our schools!

Your Director of Schools,

Dr. Del R. Phillips III, Ph.D.

We Got a Letter!!

Actually, it was addressed to the Sumner County Commission.

Here goes:

Sumner County Commission:



As parents of three children who are all honor students, we are very proud and grateful for the education they have received in the Sumner County School System their entire lives. Our daughter Brittany is a sophomore at Station Camp High School; she received a 4.0 last year as a Freshman. Our oldest son Brandon is entering 6th grade at Rucker Stewart Middle and earned a 99% in Math on his TCAP scores this year. Our youngest son Baron who is a 4th grader at Howard Elementary was bright enough to say, “Mom, why don’t you just write them a check so we can get back to school.” Attached is a picture of them on the first day of school last year ready to learn.

Sumner County Schools are all tremendous. We feel confident they are preparing students for college and life outside the classroom. Our children plan to attend Lipscomb University. Our daughter wants to be a high school geography teacher because of the great influences she has had in the classroom and the excitement she has for learning and helping others love learning too.

Our experience with Dr. Phillips has been nothing but positive. He was even concerned last year when Howard Elementary did not have funding for printer ink for the children to print their Living History Wax Museum presentations – a tremendous project by the 4th and 5th graders.

We understand most Sumner County citizens do not want their property taxes raised to help fund schools. Most people are skeptical of the government’s mismanagement of funds in the past on the federal, state and local levels. And most families want them to live within their means like they are forced to do.

However, we feel for the small amount of money each household would have to contribute ($1/week possibly), that if presented the facts, would agree to a tax increase. It’s all in how it is sold to the general public. And currently, Sumner County could use a little public relations help to be honest.


Since most politicians shy away from tax increases for fear of losing their positions, this is a difficult decision to make for most of you. Maybe there are other more creative ways to get this funding?

On another note, we need to attract more white collar jobs to Sumner County. In order to recruit these companies, we need an educated work force. Currently, we are losing big time to Williamson County on both aspects – school funding & jobs.


Whatever it takes to make our students in Sumner County and the entire state of Tennessee competitive with the nation, we need to be willing to make sacrifices.


Our prayer is that you will come to a resolution quickly so our students and teachers can get back to school as soon as possible to minimize the delay this has caused, and minimize the long-term damage lack of funding will cause our entire county.


Please watch this short video from Governor Bill Haslam. He is speaking about how Tennessee is competing against the world for jobs and “education is the key”.

http://vimeo.com/41030095   Chuck and Buffie Baril Gallatin

What Happened Last Night...

...Or, will Sumner County be back in school anytime soon?

The short answer is: NO.

Here's the breakdown:

The County Commission spent a long time talking about how individual commissioners support schools.  However, numerous proposals were put forth to reallocate revenue, raise taxes a very small amount, or in other ways give the schools $3 million to $4 million of the $7.6 million they are seeking.

Ultimately, the Commission engaged in an accounting gimmick, transferring $2.2 million they were giving schools anyway in the form of capital outlay (buildings) to the schools general fund.  This means the schools technically are $2.2 million closer to their goal .... BUT ... it also means $2.2 million worth of capital projects (buildings or additions to buildings) won't get done.  So, although some commissioners may claim they gave the schools some money, the schools actually get a NET ZERO from the Commission's move.

There is no word yet on when or if the School Board will meet again.  Indications from many Board members are that the County's actions are unacceptable and will not lead to an opening of schools any time soon. 

The Commissioners who actually voted for proposals that would have provided new money to schools (though not all the Board is requesting) were:

Ben Harris, Baker Ring, Chris Hughes, Shawn Utley, Paul Decker, David Kimbrough, Michael Guthrie, and Paul Goode.  Trish LeMarbre was not able to attend, but sent a letter indicating her support for new revenue for schools and has voted to raise revenue for schools in the past.  It should be noted that Hughes said he supports more revenue, but opposes a property tax increase to get there. 

The remaining members of the body consistently voted NO to additional funding for schools.  Commissioners even rejected a proposal to cut their own pay (a total of $144,000 a year) and dedicate that money to schools. 

David Kimbrough was among the most passionate advocates for additional funding and noted that he didn't have anywhere to be until 8:30 this morning, so he could stay with his fellow commissioners all night until they found a solution.  He pointed out that the full School Board was in attendance as well and this would be a good opportunity to have an open, public discussion of the County's priorities.  The Commission did not seem interested in that proposal. 

Paul Goode noted that the Director of Schools had warned the Commission that if they didn't solve the funding problem with last year's budget, there'd be a crisis this year.  Goode said that Commissioners pledged to work with the Board on a long-term solution last year...and have since failed to live up to that pledge. 

Perhaps most interesting, at the start of the meeting, Commission Chair Merrol Hyde asked the hundreds in attendance who supported the schools budget including a property tax increase.  Nearly the entire audience stood and raised their hands.  When he asked he did not support the budget or a tax increase, a handful of people raised their hands.

In speech after speech from Commissioners, they pointed out that an overwhelming majority of their constituents had asked them to fund schools with whatever it takes, including a tax increase.  Then, 15 of those Commissioners proceeded to vote time and again against proposals to fund the schools.

In other news...

While much of Sumner County is now focused on the closed schools, something else BIG happened on Thursday night.

Challenger Courtney Rogers defeated incumbent Debra Maggart in the 45th district state house race.  Maggart has been in the House since 2004 and recently served in the #3 leadership role as Chair of the Republican Caucus.

Now, Rogers goes on to face Democrat Jeanette Jackson in the November election.  And Maggart goes on to...

They have a petition and everything...

Some members of SURG -- Sumner United for Responsible Government -- the local Tea Party outpost, are complaining that parents got organized and started a petition and are planning a rally.  Their suggestion:  Attend the rally and speak out!  Hmm...

Automatic For the People

Since many County Commissioners are getting phone calls and emails regarding the current budget situation, some have resorted to automated voice messages or emails.

For the most part, this messages can be divided into two groups.  First, a group that says they support NO additional funding for schools (Paige Brown Strong falls in this category).  Second, a group that says they oppose any tax increase (while not explicitly ruling out another source of funding).

Combined, it seems highly unlikely that a majority of commissioners will agree on a solution tonight.  At best, Commissioners may offer a small sum of money from reserves and demand that the Board make further cuts. 

If so, the Board will likely meet again as soon as Wednesday and either propose cuts OR continue with the delay of schools until the budget is properly funded.

An email from Dr. Phillips today seems to indicate he is not interested in a short-term fix, but rather wants a long-term solution to fully fund schools and prevent "crisis" budgeting. 

School's Out Forever....

...Well, the signs in front of the schools all read:  "Until further notice, school is not in session."

So, that could be forever.  But, eventually, Sumner County students and teachers will have to go back.

For now, there is no school.

Why?

The School Board voted on Thursday night to suspend the start of school indefinitely pending a resolution to the budget impasse between the Board and the County Commission.

Interestingly, back in May, County Commissioner Jerry Stone commended Director of Schools Del Phillips for "the most transparent budget process" he'd ever witnessed.

Then, Stone joined his fellow Commissioners in telling the Board they simply won't fund the $7.6 million needed to pay for all that's in that budget.

In September of 2011, during the last edition of the now annual schools budget crisis, Director Phillips warned the Commission that failure to act to fully fund the 2011-12 budget would lead to dire consequences in 2012-13. 

The Board presented an inital 2011-12 budget that was $12 million over available funds.  The County Commission sent it back with a request to cut the budget back to only "needs."  The Board submitted a new budget -- cutting $7 million from their initial request.  The Commission then said:  We still don't want to pay for that.

Ultimately, the County Commission funded $500,000 of the Board's request. The Board cut $11.5 million from its initial proposal.  High school teachers no longer had substitutes available and had to use planning time to cover their colleagues classes.  14 positions were eliminated.  Key textbook purchases were delayed. And the Board accessed some of its reserve fund to cover other expenses.  But accessing the Board's reserves last year would mean there would be no reserves left to access in 2012-13. 

Since May, the Board has been pushing what it says is a "needs-based" budget.  All 11 Board members supported this budget request. 

But, the County Commission has said no time and again. 

In order to achieve the $7.6 million in savings, the Board would have to cut positions.  Already, the Board needs to hire 28 teachers, but instead is asking teachers to give up their planning time to cover these classes in exchange for a small stipend.  Eliminating subs for high school teachers would also save some funds.  Eliminating raises for classified employees -- who haven't had a raise in 5 years -- is another option.  Even with those measures, it is impossible to get to $7.6 million.  That means something else has to be cut.  Elementary art and music are on the table.  Other "non-required" courses may also be cut. 

Alternatively, the County Commission may decide at its emergency meeting tomorrow night at 6:30 that it can find the way to fund the budget.  Perhaps by using some of its $26 million reserve fund. 

Some County Commissioners are already giving indications of where they stand.

Commissioners Decker, LeMarbre, Utley, Guthrie, Harris, and Kimbrough have all indicated or explicitly supported a property tax increase as a means of funding the budget.  Commissioner Ring has indicated the schools need more revenue, and thus he may support a tax increase if needed. 

Commissioner Hughes has said the schools need additional funds, but that he's unwilling to support increased taxes.

Commissioner Jim Vaughn has stated he is absolutely opposed to any tax increase.  Commissioner Paige Brown Strong has said she opposes additional funds for schools at this time.

Commissioners Stone, Moser, Matthews, and Geminden have all historically opposed full funding of schools.  Commission Chair Merrol Hyde has said he doesn't believe the schools should always get the budget they propose and appears to be leaning against fully funding the budget.

County Executive Anthony Holt has said the School Board's action is "unacceptable." 

So, school's out in Sumner.  Not forever, but maybe for quite some time. 

HolidayFest Board Members Named

New Board Members join Holidayfest Board for the Sixth Annual Season of Events.


Left to right, Lynda Evjen, Beverly Cannon Jones, Eric Stamper, Roger Sevigny, Brenda Sevigny, Julie Massicotti, Connie Maynard, Tonya Elsten, and not pictured Michael Smith, Theresa Birdsong, Carol Maynord, Dean Germain.  

Will School Start Monday?

As first reported here, the Sumner County School Board meets tonight at 7:30 in study session, then at 8:00 PM in a special called meeting to address the calendar.

The issue is the school budget.  And some are saying it could delay the start of school. 

Of course, this showdown has been shaping up for some time now. 

And, it seems the use of a calendar would in fact come in handy.